Short answer: pick Shippo if you ship a modest number of Shopify orders, want a free plan to start on, and mostly need cheap labels and tracking. Pick ShipStation if you sell on several channels, have a team packing orders, or need returns, warehouse and inventory tools in the same app as your labels. Both connect to Shopify, both offer discounted carrier rates, and both let you bring your own carrier accounts. The real differences are price at low volume, how much of your fulfillment operation each one runs, and how they scale as order counts grow.

Everything below comes from each company's own pricing page and Shopify App Store listing as of November 2026. Shipping software pricing changes often, so check the linked pages before you commit.

TL;DR: there's a template for that

Create a ShipStation Label for New Shopify Orders Streamline order fulfillment by automatically generating a ShipStation label each time a Shopify order is created. This MESA workflow template fulfills all shippable items in the order, creates the shipping label in ShipStation, and adds shipping details to the order's Shopify Order Notes field. Save time and reduce manual work, ensuring a smooth and efficient shipping process.

ShipStation vs Shippo at a glance

ShipStationShippo
Free planNo. 30-day free trial, no credit card requiredYes. Starter is free for up to 30 labels a month
Entry paid planStarter from $14.99/month for 50 shipmentsPro from $19/month ($17/month billed annually)
How price scalesBy plan tier and shipments per month (50 up to 100,000)By monthly label volume; Premier is quoted by sales
Users included3 (Starter), 10 (Standard), 15 (Premium)1 (Starter), up to 5 (Pro), 15+ (Premier)
Your own carrier accountsStandard plan and upAny plan; 5 cents a label on Starter, free on Pro and Premier
Carriers200+ carriers, per its Shopify listing40+ carriers, per its Shopify listing
Store connectionsUnlimitedUnlimited
ReturnsReturn labels on Starter; returns and exchanges on StandardReturn labels on every plan
Inventory and warehouseBasic warehouse management on Standard; advanced inventory and warehouse management on PremiumNot part of the plans listed
Branded trackingBranded tracking pages and a returns portalBranded tracking page and notification emails on Pro
Shopify App Store rating4.3 from 710 reviews4.2 from 319 reviews

Pricing: what you actually pay

The pricing models are built for different stores, and that's usually what decides it.

Shippo

Shippo's pricing page lists three plans. Starter is free for up to 30 labels a month with one user, and includes carrier discounts, unlimited store connections, international shipping, automations, return labels, tracking and reporting. Connecting your own carrier account on Starter costs 5 cents a label. Pro covers 1 to 200 labels a month for up to 5 users and adds AI-estimated delivery dates, branded tracking pages, notification emails, packing slips, and chat and phone support. It's listed at $19 a month on Shippo's Shopify App Store listing and $17 a month billed annually on its pricing page, and the price rises with label volume. Premier is for very high volume and is priced by sales.

"Save up to 90% off retail shipping rates and automate the busywork."Shippo on the Shopify App Store

"Up to" matters there: the discount depends on carrier, service and package, so compare the rates on your own typical shipments before you count on it.

ShipStation

ShipStation's pricing page prices every plan by shipments per month, with no per-label fee and a 30-day free trial. At 50 shipments a month, Starter is $14.99, Standard $29.99 and Premium $349.99. At 1,000 shipments a month they're $79.99, $149.99 and $599.99. Starter tops out at 5,000 shipments; Standard and Premium go up to 100,000. Annual billing saves 20%.

The tier matters as much as the volume. Starter gives you 3 users, rate shopping, return labels and basic automations. Standard (ShipStation's most popular plan) adds 10 users, unlimited automations, combining and splitting orders, your own carrier accounts, returns and exchanges, basic warehouse management and the Shipping API. Premium adds advanced inventory and warehouse management, custom analytics and auto-routing.

Which costs less?

Under 30 labels a month, Shippo's free Starter plan is hard to beat. Between roughly 30 and 200 labels, the two land close together, and the deciding factor is which features you need: if you want your own UPS or FedEx account, that's included in Shippo Pro but needs ShipStation Standard. Once you need more than 5 users, warehouse tools or many sales channels in one queue, ShipStation's higher tiers are built for that and Shippo's equivalent is a sales conversation.

How each one works with Shopify

Both install from the Shopify App Store and pull your Shopify orders into their own dashboard, where you compare rates and buy labels.

  • Shippo says on its Shopify integration page that you can automatically import your Shopify orders, sync tracking information back to Shopify after printing labels, and send tracking notifications to customers.
  • ShipStation's app is listed as ShipStation Orders & Inventory, and it leans on multichannel selling:

"Sync orders & inventory everywhere you sell—TikTok Shop, Amazon, Walmart, & more"ShipStation on the Shopify App Store

If Shopify is your only channel, both cover the core loop: order in, label out, tracking back to Shopify, customer notified. If you also sell on marketplaces and want one packing queue for all of them, ShipStation was built around that.

Who each tool fits

Choose Shippo if

  • You ship fewer than about 200 orders a month and want to start free.
  • One person, or a small team of up to 5, buys the labels.
  • You mainly need discounted rates, labels, return labels and tracking, without warehouse features.
  • You want to use your own carrier account without moving up to a mid-tier plan.

Choose ShipStation if

  • You sell on Shopify plus marketplaces and want every order in one queue.
  • A packing team of 5 or more works from the same tool.
  • You need to combine and split orders, run a returns and exchanges portal, or manage warehouse picking.
  • You expect volume in the thousands of shipments a month and want predictable tiered pricing.

Where MESA fits: the work around your shipping app

MESA isn't a shipping app and doesn't sell labels, so it's not a replacement for either tool. It's the third piece many Shopify teams add once labels are sorted: the automations around shipping that neither app's built-in rules cover, such as logging label spend for finance, tagging orders before they reach the packing queue, or alerting the team when something goes wrong. MESA has connectors for both: ShipStation (with triggers like Order Created, Order Shipped and Shipment Created, and actions like Create Label for Order, Add Tag to Order and Hold Order) and Shippo (with triggers like Transaction Created and Track Updated, and actions like Create Shipment, Retrieve Rate and Create Batch).

With ShipStation: create the label the moment a Shopify order comes in

If every order ships the same way, you don't need someone to open ShipStation and click buy. This workflow fulfills the order's shippable items, creates the ShipStation label and writes the shipping details into the Shopify order notes.

Create a ShipStation Label for New Shopify Orders Streamline order fulfillment by automatically generating a ShipStation label each time a Shopify order is created. This MESA workflow template fulfills all shippable items in the order, creates the shipping label in ShipStation, and adds shipping details to the order's Shopify Order Notes field. Save time and reduce manual work, ensuring a smooth and efficient shipping process.

For orders that don't start in Shopify, such as warranty replacements or samples, you can also create ShipStation orders straight from a Google Form. And if your product options use hidden underscore properties, here's how to keep them off ShipStation packing slips.

With Shippo: log every label and what it cost

Shippo shows label spend in its own dashboard, but finance usually wants it in a spreadsheet next to revenue. This workflow runs each time a Shippo label is purchased, looks up the rate it was bought at, and adds the carrier, service, cost and tracking number to Google Sheets, so you can total shipping spend by carrier or month.

Log Every Shippo Shipping Label and Its Cost to Google Sheets Shippo shows label spend inside its own dashboard, but finance and ops usually want it next to everything else in a spreadsheet. This workflow runs each time a Shippo label is purchased, looks up the rate it was bought at, and adds a row to Google Sheets with the date, carrier, service, cost, tracking number and label link, so you can total shipping spend by carrier or month without exporting anything.

Whichever app you choose, the bigger gains usually come from the steps before the label, like routing and tagging orders. Our guide to order fulfillment automation for faster shipping covers which of those to automate first.

FAQs

Is ShipStation or Shippo better for Shopify?

Neither is better for every store. Shippo suits smaller Shopify stores that want a free plan and low-cost labels and tracking. ShipStation suits stores that sell on several channels, have a larger packing team, or need returns, warehouse and inventory tools in one app.

Is Shippo free?

Shippo's Starter plan is free for up to 30 labels a month with one user. You pay for postage, and connecting your own carrier account on Starter costs 5 cents a label. Paid Pro plans start at $19 a month.

Does ShipStation have a free plan?

No. ShipStation offers a 30-day free trial with no credit card required. After that, plans start at $14.99 a month for 50 shipments on Starter.

Can I use my own UPS or FedEx account?

Yes, with both. Shippo allows it on every plan (5 cents a label on Starter, free on Pro and Premier). ShipStation includes bringing your existing carrier accounts from the Standard plan up.

Can I automate ShipStation or Shippo with Shopify beyond their built-in rules?

Yes. MESA connects Shopify to both, so you can create ShipStation labels when orders come in, tag or hold orders, or log every Shippo label to Google Sheets, without writing code.